jihadica

chronicling the global jihad

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact

The Islamic State of Decline: Anticipating the Paper Caliphate

June 15, 2016 by Cole Bunzel 28 Comments

It is still too early to predict the collapse of the Islamic State, but it is telling that the group’s own media, which usually keep to a narrative of unstoppable progress and battlefield success, have begun signaling decline. Last week, an editorial in the most recent issue of the Islamic State’s weekly Arabic newsletter, al-Naba’ (“News”), well captured this new outlook. Titled “The Crusaders’ Illusions in the Age of the Caliphate,” it offers a grim view of the future, both for the Islamic State and for those seeking to destroy it. I provide a full translation below.

Much of the editorial echoes the downbeat sentiments expressed by the Islamic State’s official spokesman, Abu Muhammad al-‘Adnani, in his recent audio statement of May 21 of this year. While in that statement ‘Adnani was sure to project a measure of confidence, remarking that the Islamic State is “becoming stronger with each passing day,” some of his comments betrayed the starker reality of a caliphate under siege. This was clear in the following queries: “Do you think, America, that victory will come by killing one or more leaders?” “Do you reckon, America, that defeat is the loss of a city or the loss of territory?” Responding to his own questions, ‘Adnani declared that killing the Islamic State’s leaders would not defeat the greater “adversary”—the group itself—and that taking its land would not eliminate its “will” to fight. Even if the Islamic State were to lose all its territories, he said, it could still go back to the way it was “at the beginning,” when it was “in the desert without cities and without territory.” The allusion here is to the experience of the Islamic State of Iraq, which between 2006 and 2012 held no significant territory despite its claim to statehood. For this reason it was derided as a “paper state.” ‘Adnani is thus suggesting that even if defeated the Islamic State could take refuge in the desert, rebuild, and return anew.

The editorial in al-Naba’ emphasizes the same themes. Like ‘Adnani’s speech, it suggests that the Islamic State could soon degenerate into a paper caliphate bereft of its land and leadership. And yet, it adds, this is no matter, for the cycle of Islamic State decline and revival will simply recur. America’s victory will once again prove illusory. If America seeks to claim real victory, it will have to eliminate an “entire generation” of caliphate supporters the world over.

These prognostications offer a striking contrast with those of the Islamic State’s leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, from just two years ago. Back then, in an audio address commemorating the start of the holy month of Ramadan, Baghdadi proclaimed the dawn of “a new age,” telling his supporters to “rejoice, take heart, and hold your heads high.” Today, it is Ramadan again, but the once proud and tall Baghdadi is nowhere to be seen. His last audio address was in December 2015. It has been left to ‘Adnani and the editorial team at al-Naba’ to deliver the bad news. The message of these sources could be summed up in the phrase, “brace yourselves for a long and difficult ride.” There remains, however, a hopeful sense that Baghdadi’s “new age” will endure—an age in which the caliphate may rise and fall, but will never truly be erased.

“The Crusaders’ Illusions in the Age of the Caliphate”

The warriors of jihad did not lie against God or against the Muslims when they announced the establishment of the Islamic State. Nor did they lie when they said it would remain, God willing. And they did not lie against God or against the Muslims when they announced the return of the caliphate and chose an imam [viz., caliph] for the Muslims, as they did not lie when they said it would remain, God willing.

The crusaders and their apostates clients are under the illusion that, by expanding the scope of their military campaign to include, in addition to the provinces of Iraq and Sham, the provinces of Khurasan, the Sinai, and West Africa, as well as the Libyan provinces, they will be able to eliminate all of the Islamic State’s provinces at once, such that it will be completely wiped out and no trace of it will be left. In this they are neglecting an important fact, which is that the whole world after the announcement of the caliphate’s return has changed from how it was before its return, and that by building plans and developing strategies in view of a previous reality, they are making plans for a world that no longer exists at present, and will not exist in the future, God willing.

Just as the Iraq war before exposed the truth of the power of the world-dominating crusaders, demonstrating the possibility of defeating them and showing Muslims that jihad is the only way to establish the state and implement the sharia, so the establishment of the Islamic State revealed to them that the return of the caliphate is something possible without first having to adopt the enfeebling ideas developed by factions and parties claiming to be Islamic, which parties with their ideas sowed hopelessness in Muslims’ hearts about the possibility of establishing the religion before the appearance of the Mahdi and the descent of Jesus, on whom be peace.

Therefore, the polytheists everywhere ought to be sure that the caliphate will remain, God willing, and that they will not be able to eliminate it by destroying one of its cities or besieging another of them, or by killing a soldier, an emir, or an imam—we ask God to protect them all and maintain them as a thorn in the eyes of the polytheists and apostates. For the Muslims after today will not accept to live without an imam guiding them upon the prophetic path: an imam around whom they can gather, behind whom they can wage jihad, to whom they can deliver a fifth of the booty and pay the zakat tax, following thereby the practice of the companions, may God be pleased with them, whom the death of the Prophet, may God bless and save him, did not prevent from choosing for themselves someone to succeed him in establishing the religion and implementing the sharia.

They ought to know that after today they will not be able to deceive the Muslims with idolatrous regimes ascribing sharia qualities to themselves, or with wayward parties and organizations claiming to raise the banner of Islam, while these adopt the pagan beliefs of democracy, patriotism, and others, and make war on those who call to God’s pure oneness and seek to unite the community of Muslims.

The State of the Caliphate has shown all mankind what the true Islamic state is like, how the sharia is applied in full and not in part, how polytheism is destroyed from the earth in which God establishes the monotheists, and how “the religion is God’s entirely” (Q. 8:39). It has thus done away with all the myths of popular support, all the lies of gradualism, and all the fears of the revenge of the crusaders.

They ought to be sure that their terrorizing of Muslims will no longer be effective, that their scaring them from establishing the religion will no longer be effective either, and that the jihad warriors have rejected the argument of the unbelievers when they said, “If we follow the guidance that is with you [O Muhammad], we will be snatched away from our land” (Q. 28:57), as they have rejected their fear of those other than God and their dread of them. What their actions have begun to say is: “We will follow the guidance, establish the religion, compel the community, and fight for this till our heads are cracked open and our limbs are torn apart. Then we will meet God, having been deprived of excuse.” There is no greater evidence of this than the pledges of allegiance, one after the other, to the Commander of the Believers, in spite of the vicious crusader campaign against the Islamic State and its soldiers, to which thousands of jihad warriors have rushed from east and west to throw themselves into the furnace of this war, preferring death under the banner of the community to life in the shadow of the ignorance of factions and parties.

They ought to reevaluate and redesign their plans on this basis. If they want to achieve true victory—and they will not, God willing—then they will have to wait a long while: till an entire generation of Muslims that was witness to the establishment of the Islamic State and the return of the caliphate, and that followed the story of its standing firm against all the nations of unbelief, is wiped out—a generation that knew God’s oneness and saw its adherents, that learned how to make of the doctrine of association and dissociation a lived reality, and how to make of the Qur’an, the Prophet’s practice, and adherence to the ancestors a path of life.

They will have to wait till this entire generation is over to reproduce the generation that was raised at the hands of idolatrous rulers, that grew up under the care of wayward parties and at the hands of evil shaykhs and palace scholars. For the generation that has lived in the shadow of the caliphate, or has lived during its great battles, will be able—God willing—to keep its banner aloft, as was the generation that grew up in the shadow of the Islamic State of Iraq able to bring it back in a stronger form than before, after the crusaders and their clients thought that it had been eliminated and that its trace had vanished from the earth.

The Islamic State will remain, God willing, and the caliphate will remain, God willing, upon the prophetic method, “till there is no persecution [viz., polytheism] and the religion is God’s entirely” (Q. 8:39).

Filed Under: Islamic State

About Cole Bunzel

Cole Bunzel, the editor of Jihadica, is a research fellow in Islamic Law and Civilization at the Yale Law school.

« The Extremist Wing of the Islamic State
Who is Iyad Qunaybi? »

Comments

  1. dave says

    June 15, 2016 at 9:14 am

    I don’t think they are “signaling decline”, offering a “grim view of the future” or expressing “downbeat sentiments”. They are merely being realistic and pragmatic; their supporters are not stupid, they can see themselves what the conditions are, and these statements are merely an explanation of the present situation. It is not a shift in message nor a new narrative. You are creating a false contrast by buying into the nonsense idea that IS have been selling “a narrative of unstoppable progress and battlefield success” when IS messaging has always been based on the reality of the present situation.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. ISIS just passed a major milestone, but the group looks a lot different than it did 2 years ago : Your Partner Business says:
    June 29, 2016 at 3:16 pm

    […] who previously worked for the Department of Defense and now writes about extremist groups, noted earlier this month that the “cycle of Islamic State decline and revival” could “simply recur” […]

    Reply
  2. ISIS just passed a major milestone, but the group looks a lot different than it did 2 years ago | Business Insider says:
    June 29, 2016 at 5:36 pm

    […] who previously worked for the Department of Defence and now writes about extremist groups, noted earlier this month that the “cycle of Islamic State decline and revival” could “simply recur” […]

    Reply
  3. ISIS just passed a major milestone, but the group looks a lot different than it did 2 years ago | Best Pro Trade says:
    June 29, 2016 at 6:05 pm

    […] who previously worked for the US Department of Defense and now writes about extremist groups, noted earlier this month that the “cycle of Islamic State decline and revival” could “simply recur” […]

    Reply
  4. Islamic State made Ramadan 2016 the bloodiest ever | News Online says:
    July 7, 2016 at 1:57 pm

    […] with this rapid loss of territory, Islamic State spokesman Abu Muhammad al-Adnani issued a statement last month to prepare followers for severe setbacks and a future once again “in the desert […]

    Reply
  5. News About Islamic State made Ramadan 2016 the bloodiest ever - USA TODAY Images - News Today says:
    July 8, 2016 at 8:43 am

    […] this rapid loss of territory, the Islamic State spokesman Abu Muhammad al-Adnani released statement last month to prepare for serious enthusiasts cuff and a future again “in the desert without […]

    Reply
  6. Inside ISIS: Quietly preparing for the loss of the ‘caliphate’ | Yerepouni Daily News says:
    July 12, 2016 at 10:08 pm

    […] at Princeton University’s Near Eastern studies department who provided a translation and commentary on the al-Naba editorial in the blog Jihadica. “But they’re trying to remind people that the […]

    Reply
  7. Inside ISIS: Quietly preparing for the loss of the ‘caliphate’ | ameralkubaisi.com English says:
    July 14, 2016 at 2:52 pm

    […] at Princeton University’s Near Eastern studies department who provided a translation and commentary on the al-Naba editorial in the blog Jihadica. “But they’re trying to remind people that the […]

    Reply
  8. Islamic State readies for fall of 'caliphate' – CMOS says:
    July 15, 2016 at 3:08 am

    […] Cole Bunzel, a doctoral candidate at Princeton University’s Close to Jap reports office who delivered a translation and commentary on the al-Naba editorial for the website Jihadica. “But they are seeking to remind people today that the team has a prolonged historical past […]

    Reply
  9. The ‘Caliphate’ At 2 – What Is Said… says:
    July 16, 2016 at 6:33 am

    […] with lethal consequences far outside Iraq and Syria. Falaha effectively conceded in both the IS newsletter al-Naba and a major speech in May that the demise of IS’s statelet is approaching. The organization […]

    Reply
  10. The Caliphate at Two | The Syrian Intifada says:
    July 17, 2016 at 5:39 am

    […] lethal consequences far outside Iraq and Syria. Falaha effectively conceded in both the IS newsletter al-Naba and a major speech in May that the demise of IS’s statelet is approaching. The organization […]

    Reply
  11. Don’t celebrate ISIS setbacks too soon says:
    August 10, 2016 at 10:58 am

    […] Bob” during the American invasion of Iraq. Rather, its spokesman has frankly acknowledged that the Islamic State may lose all its land. But he promises it will return. Given the group’s recent history, it’s not an empty promise. […]

    Reply
  12. Looking At the Islamic State’s Past, Seeing its Future | The Syrian Intifada says:
    August 27, 2016 at 11:08 am

    […] in May. “Certainly not! True defeat is the loss of willpower and desire to fight.” An editorial in IS’s newsletter, al-Naba, echoed this, saying that the only way IS would be defeated is if the “entire […]

    Reply
  13. Obituary: Taha Falaha (Abu Muhammad al-Adnani) | The Syrian Intifada says:
    August 30, 2016 at 11:56 pm

    […] back to an earlier stage of its revolutionary war, namely insurgency and terrorism, and making public preparations to explain this development to its supporters. The most detailed explanation came from Falaha, who […]

    Reply
  14. Abu Muhammad al-Adnani & Jaysh Khalid ibn al-Waleed says:
    September 1, 2016 at 2:42 am

    […] Adnani’s death does not mean the end of the IS project. The article follows a wider trend of recent IS media pushback against the notion that territorial and battlefield losses spell the doom of the […]

    Reply
  15. How the Islamic State Is Spinning the Mosul Battle – The Atlantic | | Nine Most Likely Words From Congress says:
    October 20, 2016 at 1:31 pm

    […] that this was perfectly fine, received more attention from Islamic State media, notably from, among others, the al-Naba newspaper editorial board. This re-framing—casting the […]

    Reply
  16. How the Islamic State Is Spinning the Mosul Battle - The Atlantic - Nationwide Dispensaries says:
    October 20, 2016 at 2:00 pm

    […] that this was perfectly fine, received more attention from Islamic State media, notably from, among others, the al-Naba newspaper editorial board. This re-framing—casting the […]

    Reply
  17. How the Islamic State Is Spinning the Mosul Battle - The Atlantic - The Cannabidiol Oils Domain says:
    October 20, 2016 at 2:01 pm

    […] that this was perfectly fine, received more attention from Islamic State media, notably from, among others, the al-Naba newspaper editorial board. This re-framing—casting the […]

    Reply
  18. KEEP ON PUSHING! ASSESSING FURTHER STRATEGIES AGAISNT THE ISLAMIC STATE – STRATEGY BRIEFING says:
    July 18, 2017 at 5:43 pm

    […] [2] The Islamic State of Decline: Anticipating the Paper Caliphate – http://www.jihadica.com/the-islamic-state-of-decline/ […]

    Reply
  19. The Myth of ISIS's Strategic Brilliance - Daily Trends says:
    July 20, 2017 at 11:30 am

    […] Adnani argued, the only real defeat would come with the end of the will to keep fighting. An editorial in the ISIS newsletter al-Naba’ in June 2016 reflected similar ideas to Adnani’s […]

    Reply
  20. The Mythe of Strategic Brilliance d'ISIS - Grand Requin Blanc says:
    July 20, 2017 at 11:40 am

    […] véritable défaite viendrait avec la fin de la volonté de continuer à se battre. Un éditorial dans le bulletin d'information ISIS al-Naba 'en juin 2016 reflète des idées similaires au discours […]

    Reply
  21. The Myth of ISIS’s Strategic Brilliance | News Beat Now says:
    July 20, 2017 at 11:46 am

    […] Adnani argued, the only real defeat would come with the end of the will to keep fighting. An editorial in the ISIS newsletter al-Naba’ in June 2016 reflected similar ideas to Adnani’s […]

    Reply
  22. The Myth of ISIS's Strategic Brilliance | OSINT says:
    July 21, 2017 at 10:04 am

    […] Adnani argued, the only real defeat would come with the end of the will to keep fighting. An editorial in the ISIS newsletter al-Naba’ in June 2016 reflected similar ideas to […]

    Reply
  23. The Myth of ISIS’s Strategic Brilliance says:
    July 23, 2017 at 1:41 pm

    […] Adnani argued, the only real defeat would come with the end of the will to keep fighting. An editorial in the ISIS newsletter al-Naba’ in June 2016 reflected similar ideas to Adnani’s […]

    Reply
  24. Caliphate in Disarray: Theological Turmoil in the Islamic State jihadica says:
    October 3, 2017 at 10:50 pm

    […] in which the Prophet and his companions prevailed over an extend siege by their enemies, and the suggestion that the Islamic State can somehow “retreat to the desert,” recover its strength, and reconquer […]

    Reply
  25. The Islamic State’s Media Apparatus and its New Spokesman | The Syrian Intifada says:
    March 16, 2018 at 4:28 pm

    […] reins at a time when IS is falling back from its overt control of territory. IS’s message to its followers in preparation for the impending collapse of its statelet has essentially two parts: (1) this is a […]

    Reply
  26. Signs of Recovery for the Islamic State | Kyle Orton's Blog says:
    November 22, 2018 at 4:40 am

    […] the last year, IS has crystallized this view that the caliphate is more a cause than a destination, presenting the impending loss of its twin capitals, Mosul and Raqqa, as merely one stage in a cycle, part of […]

    Reply
  27. Parsing the Islamic State’s Nice Attack Claims - new-ac says:
    June 25, 2019 at 6:31 am

    […] be even more  opportunistic moves. The Islamic State’s Modus Operandi might be changing, as by its own admission, it banks on “an entire generation of Muslims that was witness to the establishment of the […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply to ISIS just passed a major milestone, but the group looks a lot different than it did 2 years ago | Business Insider Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

“… an obsessive and multilingual crew who monitor and debate terrorist Web statements like Talmudic scholars poring over a manuscript” – New York Times

Recent Posts

  • Caliph Incognito: The Ridicule of Abu Ibrahim al-Hashimi November 14, 2019
  • How Did the Islamic State Pick Its New Leader? November 1, 2019
  • Mourning Morsi: The Death of an Islamist and Jihadi Divisions September 27, 2019
  • Kill the Caliph! The Islamic State’s evolution from an integrated to a fragmented group May 20, 2019
  • Divine Test or Divine Punishment? Explaining Islamic State Losses March 11, 2019

Categories

Copyright © 2019 - jihadica | design by WPStuffs